This publish might comprise affiliate hyperlinks. Please see my full privateness protection for particulars.
Studded with gluten-free cookie dough bites, this no-churn Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream is summer time season indulgence in a bowl! This creamy selfmade chocolate ice cream is in fact sweetened with maple syrup and made with out sweetened condensed milk.

I don’t make ice cream sometimes, nevertheless as soon as I do… I make ice cream!
Reading: Chocolate peanut butter cookie dough ice cream
Constructive, plain vanilla ice cream is great and will be utilized in so many different strategies (like topping Blackberry Peach Pie as an illustration). Nevertheless as soon as I’m going to the difficulty of developing selfmade ice cream, I would love it to be worth my time.
And good buddy, this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream is so nicely definitely worth the time it takes to make – and to say its determine.
I’m not often an unlimited fan of chocolate ice cream. I’m on a regular basis drawn to espresso, citrus, cookie dough, or pistachio flavours over chocolate. Nevertheless typically, you merely need an unlimited ol’ bowl of chocolate peanut butter indulgence, amiright?

Also: Corn on cob stove top
This no-churn ice cream is so creamy and chocolatey. We’re using the nice issues proper right here – solely probably the greatest 70% or bigger darkish chocolate goes into this recipe. Using precise chocolate in its place of cacao powder makes all the distinction to the flavour.
In truth, you could depart the cookie dough out and have a delicious chocolate ice cream in your arms. Nevertheless who would choose that alternative?! For a cookie dough lover like me, the gluten-free pb dough bites are necessary.
For individuals who’re a cookie dough fan or peanut butter/chocolate combo fan, you are going to need this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream in your life this summer time season! You obtained’t be dissatisfied.
Table of Contents
Why you’ll love this recipe
- This peanut butter cookie dough ice cream is naturally sweetened with maple syrup, retaining it refined sugar free. It’s moreover gluten-free, due to the almond flour used to make the cookie dough bites.
- I obtained’t mislead you, this recipe takes a bit little bit of time and love to arrange, nevertheless it’s not a complicated course of. In fact, I might argue that it’s pretty easy to do! The hardest half is tempering the eggs with the latest milk mixture, nevertheless do you have to observe the recipe instructions, you’ll be constructive.
- This Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream is completely no-churn! Who has the room for an ice cream maker? I sure don’t.
- Not like many various no-churn ice cream recipes in the marketplace, this recipe doesn’t use sweetened condensed milk!
- This recipe is small-batch, making only one 1/2 pints of ice cream. Good for smaller households.

Strategies to make no-churn ice cream with out sweetened condensed milk
Sweetened condensed milk is utilized in no-churn ice cream recipes for 3 principal causes: to sweeten, to thicken, and in order so as to add a creamy part. Nevertheless we’ll merely make ice cream that is super creamy, thick, and sweet with out it.
The rationale sweetened condensed milk is a popular sweetener choice is on account of it’s clear, not granulated like widespread refined sugar. However, by using a liquid sweetener like maple syrup, agave syrup, or honey, we’ll sweeten our custard base and skip the granules (and the condensed milk).
Read more: How to descale keurig with vinegar
To make no-churn ice cream creamy, merely use heavy or double cream! For this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream recipe, I moreover chosen to utilize whole milk together with the cream to create a wonderful lush texture.
Lastly, to thicken the ice cream, we’ll use egg yolks and heat. It’s the old school methodology and works utterly correctly. Why restore it if it ain’t broke?
Substances on this cookie dough ice cream
- Double cream: That’s key to creating a wonderful creamy ice cream base.
- Full milk: The higher cream content material materials in full fat cow’s milk helps produce probably the greatest texture on this selfmade ice cream recipe.
- Maple syrup: Our pure sweetener of choice for this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream. Be joyful to substitute agave syrup.
- Vanilla extract: Necessary for seasoning the custard.
- Egg yolks: Egg yolks are key to thickening our custard base.
- Darkish chocolate: Creates basically essentially the most chocolatey ice cream in all the land!
- Pure peanut butter: To make the cookie dough bites and to drizzle and swirl!
- Sea salt: Peanut butter’s most interesting good buddy. Solely a pinch makes all the distinction throughout the cookie dough.
- Almond flour: To create the cookie dough and preserve it gluten-free.

Strategies to make chocolate peanut butter cookie dough ice cream
The prep work for this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream is a tad involved, nevertheless it’s really not that subtle. It’s principally various whisking and watching to make sure the custard doesn’t burn. After that, the freezer does lots of the work! Proper right here’s the precise approach to make it:
- Whisk the egg yolks in an enormous bowl.
- Add the moist substances to a saucepan and produce to a scalding degree.
- Temper the eggs with half the latest cream mixture.
- Add the tempered eggs once more to the pot with the chocolate and heat until thickened.
- Decant proper right into a freezer-proof container. Let come to room temperature.
- Freeze.
- Make the cookie dough bites.
- Take away the ice cream. Add the cookie dough bites and stir correctly.
- Freeze.
Concepts for making this recipe utterly
- Please use double (heavy) cream and full-fat milk. That’s one recipe the place you don’t have to make substitutions to the substances. Using a cream or milk with a lower fat content material materials will finish in a watered down ice cream and won’t thicken correct.
- Equally, use a wonderful prime quality darkish chocolate. Ideally one with 70% or bigger cocoa. It’ll assure your Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream is rich and chocolatey.
- For individuals who can’t get maple syrup, agave syrup or honey might even work.
- Stir the ice cream somewhat nicely on the halfway degree when you add throughout the cookie dough gadgets. It’ll assure a clear and creamy ice cream.
- Ensure the container you’re using is airtight. The first time I made this ice cream, I froze it in a loaf pan with aluminum foil extreme, which resulted in an “icier” ice cream. Using an airtight container (I exploit one with suction and clips) will assure your ice cream stays as creamy as attainable.

Seeking further refined sugar free frozen desserts?
Do-it-yourself Vanilla Ice CreamFrozen Margarita TartNo Bake Strawberry Lemon Cheesecake BarsNo Bake Espresso CheesecakeWatermelon Rosé Sorbet
For individuals who make this recipe, let me know by snapping a picture and tagging me on Instagram @naturallysweet_kitchen. I like seeing your creations and sharing them in my Tales. Or let me know you are eager on this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream by leaving a comment and rating underneath!